6/11/ · Step 1: Identify the CONTENTION of the material. Remember: The CONTENTION is what the writer/author/ artist/person is trying to ARGUE. Try to sum up their argument in a sentence! 3. Step 2: Identify the TONE of the material Argument analysis is relevant to various applications aside from just debating in courtroom sessions. The Five Elements of an Argument Generally, there are five basic elements to find in an argument. They are the introduction, narration, confirmation, refutation, and summation 9/18/ · Essays with two or more main subjects are often structured around comparing and contrasting. For example, a literary analysis essay might compare two different texts, and an argumentative essay might compare the strengths of different arguments
21+ SAMPLE Argument Analysis Templates in PDF | MS Word
Click here to return to the Home Page. Sally A. Student Sept. Thompson Old-Fashioned Sexist, Racist, and Classist Values: A Review of Charles Murray's "The Coming White Underclass" In a Wall Street Argument analysis essay structure article entitled "The Coming White Underclass," conservative writer Charles Murray foretells a potential doom for American society in the form of widespread high rates of illegitimacy.
Using trends in black crime rates and black unemployment as cautionary illustrations, argument analysis essay structure, Murray predicts that white culture will be catastrophically affected by the recent increases in illegitimacy rates among poor white women. To combat the rising rates of argument analysis essay structure, Murray proposes that single mothers should no longer receive government support, forcing them to either involve other responsible adults from their families or communities, or else to give up their babies for adoption or to orphanages.
In short, Murray sees his proposal as a shift back to the values and social norms of America's 's. Although many of the problems he outlines are indeed pressing and troubling, Murray clearly fails to understand the underlying causes of illegitimacy, making his attempt to form solutions extremely misguided. Murray makes a crucial error in logic when he attributes a variety of social ills to illegitimacy.
He argues the "trend lines on black crime, dropout from the the labor force, and illegitimacy all shifted sharply upward as argument analysis essay structure overall black illegitimacy rate passed 25 percent" Ramage and Bean Murray probably has his causality backwards. Murray admits that "white illegitimacy is overwhelming a lower-class phenomenon" Ramage and Bean 28 without stopping to consider that whatever measures he suggests for eradicating illegitimacy must take into consideration the causes of illegitimacy in order to work effectively.
When Murray does attempt to identify the root causes of illegitimacy, he comes up with a simplified and sexist version of puppy love. Surely the situation is much more complex than Murray calculates here. If this statement were true, then all races and economic classes of American society would suffer equally the plague of illegitimacy.
The reality of illegitimacy, argument analysis essay structure, however, is much more more complex and includes such variables as race, education, and poverty. Additionally, Murray provides no evidence that "girls think babies are endearing. Murray, however, argument analysis essay structure, assumes that girls are asexual beings, giving in to sex in order to have living dolls to love.
If the real reason girls ended up with babies is because they like to sleep with boys to continue in Murray's "cutesy" rhetoricthen a real solution would focus, argument analysis essay structure, say, on birth control methods to prevent the babies in the first place. Also troubling in Murray's essay is his repeated targeting of black America as an example of what could happen to white America.
What happens within the black community whose ancestors were the legal property of white slave-owners, who were granted civil rights barely a generation ago, and who face current and continual discrimination to this date, can hardly form an appropriate analogy to the white situation.
Too many variables are unique to the black situation for anyone derive sweeping conclusions applicable to the entire white culture. Murray has essentially divided America into a white us versus a black them, and he cautions "us" against ending up like "them.
It cannot survive the same epidemic among whites" Ramage and Bean Disguised as a gritty utilitarian philosophy of the greatest good for the greatest number, argument analysis essay structure, Murray's "brutal truth" is little more than racist self-interest shrugging off the plight of millions of black Americans. Very little in Murray's essay is worth salvaging.
He identifies a pressing issue in our culture and earnestly attempts to present a solution for it, but he lacks a fundamental understanding of the real causes of illegitimacy argument analysis essay structure the poor, and, even more damning, makes no real attempt to uncover them.
Instead, he reduces the problem to simply: "boys like to sleep with girls. His out-dated solutions won't solve our modern problems as we face the new millennium.
How To Write An Analytical Essay: What Is It?
, time: 5:24Analysing Argument - what, when, how, why method | Lisa's Study Guides
Argument analysis is relevant to various applications aside from just debating in courtroom sessions. The Five Elements of an Argument Generally, there are five basic elements to find in an argument. They are the introduction, narration, confirmation, refutation, and summation 2/19/ · The arguments an author uses can usually fall into one of three categories - ethos, pathos, or logos. Ethos arguments are about credibility, for example, using quotes from credible sources or writing about a personal anecdote. Pathos arguments target the emotion of the reader This is an excellent argument analysis. the title to the conclusion, the analysis has been constructed as a unified whole. The summary is objective and accurate, the thesis clearly stated at the end of the first paragraph, the body supports the claim made in
No comments:
Post a Comment